The Secret to Writing a Killer Multiple-Choice Question

The Secret to Writing a Killer Multiple-Choice Question

Multiple-choice questions (MCQs) are the backbone of quizzes, exams, and training programs. When done right, they challenge, engage, and even entertain participants. When done poorly, they can be frustrating, confusing, or even misleading.

So, what makes a great multiple-choice question? What are the biggest mistakes to avoid? And how do you strike the perfect balance between accessibility and challenge?

Let’s dive in.

Why Multiple-Choice Questions Matter

Before we get into the details, it’s worth considering why MCQs are such a powerful tool:

  • They’re efficient. Unlike open-ended questions, MCQs provide clear options, making them easy to grade and analyse.
  • They test more than memory. A well-structured MCQ can assess critical thinking, problem-solving, and applied knowledge.
  • They create engagement. Well-written questions make quizzes and tests fun, interactive, and rewarding.

But not all MCQs are created equal. Here’s how to make sure yours stand out.

Common Pitfalls to Avoid

1. Obvious Wrong Answers ("Too Easy")

If the incorrect options (distractors) are wildly unrealistic, the question becomes trivial. For example:

❌ What is the capital of France?
A) Paris
B) Banana
C) Mars
D) A plate of spaghetti

➡ Why this is bad: Even someone with no knowledge can immediately rule out three of the four options.

✅ Fix: Ensure all answer choices are at least somewhat plausible.

🔹 Better Example:
What is the capital of France?
A) Paris
B) Lyon
C) Marseille
D) Bordeaux

Now, even if someone isn’t sure, they have to think critically.

2. Trick Questions ("Too Hard")

Some quiz creators love to trip people up, but a question should test knowledge, not your ability to confuse.

❌ Which of the following is NOT an incorrect answer to this question?

➡ Why this is bad: If participants have to re-read a question five times to understand it, it's a problem.

✅ Fix: Keep questions straightforward and unambiguous.

🔹 Better Example:
Which of these elements is NOT a metal?
A) Iron
B) Gold
C) Oxygen
D) Copper

Now, the challenge is about knowledge, not deciphering the wording.

3. Unbalanced Answer Lengths (Making the Correct Answer Obvious)

People subconsciously expect the longest, most detailed answer to be correct.

❌ Which programming language is primarily used for iOS app development?
A) Java
B) Python
C) Swift, which was developed by Apple in 2014 and has since become the industry standard
D) C++

➡ Why this is bad: The longest answer stands out as the correct one.

✅ Fix: Keep answer lengths roughly equal.

🔹 Better Example:
Which programming language is primarily used for iOS app development?
A) Java
B) Python
C) Swift
D) C++

Now, no answer jumps out unfairly.

4. Too Many "All of the Above" or "None of the Above"

These can sometimes work, but overusing them makes patterns easy to guess.

❌ If half of the quiz answers are “All of the Above,” participants start selecting them by default.

✅ Fix: Use sparingly and only when it genuinely makes sense.

Top Tips for Writing Great MCQs

Now that we’ve seen some common pitfalls, let’s look at what makes a multiple-choice question truly shine.

1. Keep It Concise

The best questions get straight to the point.

❌ In the year 1492, which famous European explorer, who was sponsored by the Spanish monarchy and is well known for his journey across the Atlantic Ocean, reached what is now known as the Americas?

✅ Better: Which European explorer reached the Americas in 1492?

Clear and direct questions lead to a better quiz experience.

2. Use a Mix of Difficulty Levels

A great quiz has a balance of easy, medium, and challenging questions.

  • Easy questions build confidence.
  • Medium questions keep people engaged.
  • Difficult questions create differentiation among participants.

✅ Tip: Arrange questions from easiest to hardest for a smooth difficulty curve.

3. Vary Your Question Types

Not all multiple-choice questions need to be basic factual recall. Consider:

  • Application-based questions: Instead of asking for a definition, give a scenario.
  • Logic-based questions: Require problem-solving rather than simple memorization.

🔹 Example: Instead of asking “What does SWOT stand for?”, ask:

"If a company is evaluating its internal strengths and weaknesses, which analysis tool is it using?"
A) PESTLE
B) SWOT
C) Porter’s Five Forces
D) BCG Matrix

4. Distractors Should Be Plausible, But Incorrect

Wrong answers should make people think, not laugh.

❌ What is the main ingredient in guacamole?
A) Avocado
B) Sand
C) Motor oil
D) Cheese

✅ Better:
A) Avocado
B) Green peppers
C) Spinach
D) Zucchini

Here, every answer feels plausible, making the question more effective.

5. Playtest Your Questions

Even experienced quizmasters sometimes write bad questions. Always test your quiz with colleagues or friends before using it.

  • If everyone gets it right immediately, it might be too easy.
  • If everyone struggles and guesses, it might be too hard or unclear.

Adjust accordingly for balance.

Final Thoughts

Writing a great multiple-choice question is both an art and a science. By avoiding common pitfalls and following best practices, you can create quizzes that are engaging, challenging, and effective—whether for a trivia night, an employee training session, or an educational test.

Want to put these strategies into action? Follow the Raglan Quizco blog for more expert quiz-writing tips!

What’s Next?

  • ✅ Follow us for more quiz-building insights.
  • ✅ Looking for ready-made, high-quality quizzes? Check out Raglan Quizco's free trial and see the difference a well-crafted quiz makes!
Back to blog